Dancing in the Dark/No Surrender – What keeps us human is the ability to keep dreaming. Those romantic dreams remain forty years later. #MusicisLife #TedTocksCovers #BruceSpringsteen #StevenVanZandt

It’s been forty years since Bruce Springsteen released his ‘Born in the U.S.A.’ album.

Forty years?

I recently saw a clip from Canadian actor Brent Butt where he candidly pointed how rapidly the years are flying by.

Okay I just did the math and here is how it how it breaks down. If I, today, listen to music that was popular when I was in high school it’s the same as high school me, listening to music that was popular during World War II. Isn’t that a fun numerical tidbit that isn’t the emotional equivalent of a rhinoceros standing on my groin.”

It may sound better coming from him.

But we can’t stop time. We can look back through the years because this album brings back great memories. Let it be said here and now that ‘Born in the U.S.A.’ is by no means Bruce Springsteen’s best album nor does it approach the top of my list of favourites from The Boss, but it does offer one of my favourite Springsteen songs. Read on for more, as we take a trip through the past.

Back in the early ‘80s, Bruce Springsteen was on an incredible run. Following ‘The River’ he managed to shift gears with the haunting acoustic release, ‘Nebraska’. Pretty much simultaneously, he was working on material that would become ‘Born in the U.S.A.’ Trying to sort through the timeline of his prolific creativity during this period is the source of endless fascination. It is estimated that he wrote over 80 songs during this two-year creative exploration. With so many songs to choose from it became a matter of sorting it all out and then deciding the most suitable way to present the versatile tracks. In the end, this may be ‘Born in the U.S.A.’s greatest quality.

It’s rock and roll, folk and rockabilly with a touch of ‘80s synth pop and some obvious commercialism. This point brings us to phase one of today’s feature.

Bruce Springsteen thought he was done, but Jon Landau insisted that he write something that could be offered to the radio market as a lead single. For about a decade Springsteen had flown close to the space where #1 records reside. He wrote ‘Blinded By the Light’ which became a #1 for Manfred Mann. He co-wrote ‘Because the Night’ with Patti Smith, and later in the ‘70s ‘Fire’ was a hit for The Pointer Sisters.

In 1982, he released ‘Nebraska’ which was a complete departure from ‘The River’ so as much as his popularity was seemingly at its peak, it was Landau’s contention that he needed to come out strong with his next album. This approach didn’t sit well with Springsteen, because he felt it may come across as contrived. Following an evening of heated debate, he went home and wrote a song about what he perceived to be the pressure to produce, and how at times this was at odds with his integrity as an artist.

Jon [Landau] had been bothering me to write a single, which is something he rarely does. But he did that day. And he wanted something direct. That seemed to be what he was hitting on me for at the time. I was angry. I had written a lot of songs and was kind of fed up with the whole thing. We’d been making the record for a long time and I was bored with the whole situation.”

He made his way home and rather than go to bed angry he began to write down his thoughts. It became a classic case of, if you ever want to know how you feel, start writing.

Forty years later we marvel at the result.

I get up in the evening
And I ain’t got nothing to say
I come home in the morning
I go to bed feeling the same way
I ain’t nothing but tired
Man, I’m just tired and bored with myself
Hey there baby, I could use just a little help

You can’t start a fire
You can’t start a fire without a spark
This gun’s for hire
Even if we’re just dancing in the dark

Message keeps getting clearer
Radio’s on and I’m moving ’round the place
I check my look in the mirror
I wanna change my clothes, my hair, my face
Man, I ain’t getting nowhere
I’m just living in a dump like this
There’s something happening somewhere
Baby, I just know that there is

You can’t start a fire
You can’t start a fire without a spark
This gun’s for hire
Even if we’re just dancing in the dark

You sit around getting older
There’s a joke here somewhere and it’s on me
I’ll shake this world off my shoulders
Come on, baby, the laugh’s on me

Stay on the streets of this town
And they’ll be carving you up all right
They say you gotta stay hungry
Hey, baby, I’m just about starving tonight
I’m dying for some action
I’m sick of sitting ’round here trying to write this book
I need a love reaction
Come on now, baby, gimme just one look

You can’t start a fire
Sitting ’round crying over a broken heart
This gun’s for hire
Even if we’re just dancing in the dark
You can’t start a fire
Worrying about your little world falling apart
This gun’s for hire
Even if we’re just dancing in the dark

Imagine being at the height of your popularity and feeling like this? In hindsight, we know that he still hadn’t hit the peak of a career that is now over a half century and counting.

When all was said and done, ‘Dancing in the Dark’ made it all the way to #2 on the Billboard Hot 100. It was prevented from hitting the summit by Duran Duran and ‘The Reflex’ and later ‘When Doves Cry’ by Prince. The fact that ‘Dancing in the Dark’ didn’t make #1 was of minimal consequence because over the next 18 months ‘Born in the U.S.A.’ managed to produce a staggering, seven top 10 singles.

‘Cover Me’ – #7

Born in the U.S.A.’ – #9

I’m on Fire’ – #6

‘Glory Days’ – #5

‘I’m Goin’ Down’ – #9

‘My Hometown’ – #6

This became a source of intense pride for Bruce Springsteen because through it all, despite all of his misgivings, self-doubt, intense pressure and scrutiny he managed to do it his way.

I love this quote from the man himself.

My ‘Born in the U.S.A.’ songs were direct and fun and stealthily carried the undercurrents of ‘Nebraska’.”

For this listener, ‘Nebraska’ is the epicenter of the Bruce Springsteen library. Everything flows from that space. The fact that so much of ‘Born in the U.S.A.’ was created within that time period only lends itself to the value of these songs.

When commercialism is organic it cannot be criticized. In many ways it was the perfect storm and Bruce Springsteen steered the ship through some turbulent waters.

Through the years there have been several magnificent covers of ‘Dancing in the Dark’. Part of the beauty of sharing this feature has been spending a lot of time listening to them as I write. Like so many times before, it has given me the opportunity to hear this song again and truly understand where Bruce Springsteen was coming from when he wrote it. From the outside it seemed as though Bruce had it all, but he was making it pretty clear that his life was lacking something. If you have read Bruce Springsteen’s autobiography ‘Born to Run’ you will understand his struggles with self-doubt and depression. Being pushed by Jon Landau in this period would have created significant internal conflict between his musical integrity and his desire to be the best.

Ironically, the vast range of emotions Bruce Springsteen was experiencing as he seemingly conjured ‘Dancing in the Dark’ out of thin air may be reflected best in this cross section of covers. Check them out for yourself and you will see what I mean.

Enjoy a revitalized Tina Turner who delivers it in her ‘in your face’ style. If we could bottle that energy. What a gift.

When I saw that Mary Chapin Carpenter was among the 100+ artists who have covered ‘Dancing in the Dark’ I was intrigued, but when I listened to it, I was instantly blown away, right from her honest introduction.

This is a bummer song by somebody else. “

She delivers this like she was standing over Bruce’s shoulder when he wrote it. Mary released this on her 1999 album ‘Almost Home’.

In 2002, Pete Yorn broke out with his acclaimed album ‘musicforthemorningafter’

This captures the mood. The harmonica makes it very contemplative and the piano brings the emotion of the cover to a boiling point.

A few years later in 2006, Tegan and Sara blended their captivating vocals with Bruce Springsteen’s honest lyrics and this was the result. I love their harmonies. The guitar work is a powerful companion. They repeat “There is something happening somewhere” which tells the story. The songwriter feels like they are missing something. Life is passing them by.

Listen to this version by Scottish singer/songwriter Amy MacDonald who explains that this is actually a cover of her own cover. She delivers like it is sage advice with the orchestral accompaniment of The German Philharmonic Orchestra. This is from a live performance in 2010.

One year later in 2011, here is former Straycats bassist Lee Rocker offering his take on ‘Dancing in the Dark’. He keeps it simple and then it builds. This cover has a nice groove like a train picking up speed.

I first heard Ruth Moody’s cover version of ‘Dancing in the Dark’ on Tom Power’s morning show on CBC Radio. Each morning Power did a segment called ‘Under the Covers’ where he offered a quality cover version of well-known songs. So many times, he exposed me to new artists and the breadth of talent that existed far outside of the mainstream. Upon reflection, this may have been the first cover of “Dancing in the Dark’ I had ever heard. So, in this moment I offer my thanks to Tom Power who now hosts the incredible CBC interview show called ‘Q’ which is also a must listen for music and entertainment fans. This segment is among a handful of shows that inspired Ted Tocks Covers. It says here, that Ruth Moody should be a household name in Canada. Check out the work with her band or as part of the Wailin’ Jennys.

Another artist that I first heard on ‘Mornings with Tom Power’ was Vance Joy, who is from Melbourne, Australia. Around the time he burst onto the music scene with ‘Riptide’ he put together this tidy cover of ‘Dancing in the Dark’ which he performed on Sirius XM’s ‘The Spectrum’ channel. This is so good. Just a guy and his guitar. Strip it right down and it bares the soul of the artist who is delivering the message.

Here we have another special message. Enjoy John Legend who enjoys a mutual admiration society with Bruce Springsteen. Legend explains how he came to admire Bruce Springsteen’s work as a result of his association with Jimmy Fallon’s band. During the conversation, Howard Stern captures exactly why I write Ted Tocks Covers.

I love when an artist like yourself takes something that you’re not typically into and you kind of make it your own.”

Quest Love helped him make a cool, jazzy, dark version and the end result was getting street cred from Bruce Springsteen’s loyal fans.

Just listen.

Looking back, it is hard to imagine thirty-five years ago and thinking that we would be listening to an industry giant like Trevor Horn adapting Bruce Springsteen’s iconic release. Here is Trevor Horn with The Sarm Orchestra and Gabrielle Aplin. This is stunning.

Remember ‘Beautiful’? Here is James Blunt and an equally beautiful cover of ‘Dancing in the Dark’. This time the piano becomes the focal point and it delivers the emotional side of Bruce Springsteen’s very personal lyrics. This is from BBC Radio 2 and the Zoe Ball Breakfast Show.

Remember the opening clip of today’s feature that addresses the reality that time is simply flying by? Here is a band called The Molly Ringwalds who Ted Tocks Covers has featured on several occasions. They do a great job capturing the nostalgia of the ‘80s. This helps us to accept that almost forty years have passed since ‘The Breakfast Club’ and ‘Sixteen Candles’.

I See Me, And I Don’t Like What I See, I Really Don’t.”

One thing is for sure, mental health was a serious issue four decades ago too. It was all in the nuance. It was difficult to come right out and say it. We have come a long way, but there is still a long way to go.

This segues nicely into a phenomenal Canadian act called Walk Off the Earth who have been huge advocates for mental health related initiatives (see ‘You Don’t Know How it Feels’)

Keeping it north of the border, here is the talented Shawn Mendes who brings The Boss to a whole new generation. Mendes is another artist who has been very open about his mental health issues. He famously opted to take some personal time to revitalize himself. The message keeps getting clearer.

I get up in the evening
And I ain’t got nothing to say
I come home in the morning
I go to bed feeling the same way
I ain’t nothing but tired
Man, I’m just tired and bored with myself
Hey there baby, I could use just a little help”

The current generation does it their way. They have it right.

Before I sign off, there is a song from ‘Born in the U.S.A. that says more about Bruce Springsteen’s career than any other. For that we need to thank Bruce’s blood brother; the great Little Steven Van Zandt. During the recording of ‘Born in the U.S.A.’ things got a little tense. There were a lot of pieces to the puzzle and the direction was not very clear for everyone who thought they played a role in the process. As mentioned, Jon Landau and Bruce Springsteen were temporarily at odds. The E Street Band were at the mercy of Bruce’s beckoning. Van Zandt had his heart set on his own solo career which yielded his much-heralded album, ‘Voice of America’ (see ‘I Am a Patriot’). When Van Zandt heard about the final track listing for ‘Born in the U.S.A.’ he told his friend that the album was missing the best song. He was adamant that Springsteen include ‘No Surrender’. Van Zandt felt that ‘No Surrender’ acted as a bridge between Springsteen’s early career and what he was working on in the present moment. Not releasing this track would have been a gross injustice. Bruce listened.

The question related to ‘No Surrender’ was how to present it to his devoted audience.

It was a song I was uncomfortable with. You don’t hold out and triumph all the time in life. You compromise, you suffer defeat; you slip into life’s gray areas.”

As Bruce later stated before a Toronto audience.

This is a song about life when you find someone to share it with.”

 One thing that you will note on the album credits is that Van Zandt did not play on the album track that harkens back to the rock and roll style of the early ’60s. Little Steven knew his role. He was Bruce’s confidante and his opinion mattered. This is how this deeply personal track managed to make its way onto ‘Born in the U.S.A.’

Well, we busted out of class
Had to get away from those fools
We learned more from a three-minute record, baby
Than we ever learned in school
Tonight I hear the neighborhood drummer sound
I can feel my heart begin to pound
You say you’re tired and you just want to close your eyes
And follow your dreams down

Well we made a promise we swore we’d always remember
No retreat, baby, no surrender
Like soldiers in the winter’s night with a vow to defend
No retreat, baby, no surrender

Well, now young faces grow sad and old
And hearts of fire grow cold
We swore blood brothers against the wind
I’m ready to grow young again
And hear your sister’s voice calling us home
Across the open yards
Well maybe we’ll cut someplace of our own
With these drums and these guitars

Well we made a promise we swore we’d always remember
No retreat, baby, no surrender
Like soldiers in the winter’s night with a vow to defend
No retreat, baby, no surrender

Now on the street tonight the lights grow dim
The walls of my room are closing in
There’s a war outside still raging
You say it ain’t ours anymore to win
I want to sleep beneath
Peaceful skies in my lover’s bed
With a wide open country in my eyes
And these romantic dreams in my head

Well we made a promise we swore we’d always remember
No retreat, baby, no surrender
Like soldiers in the winter’s night with a vow to defend
No retreat, baby, no surrender”

Let’s enjoy a run of quality covers of ‘No Surrender’.

We begin with Bruce Springsteen and his friend Eddie Vedder. This is from twenty years ago. Listen to the New Jersey crowd sing along. Yet another magical Bruce Springsteen moment.

Here is a fun offering from the popular Boston band, Dropkick Murphys who have frequently professed their admiration for Bruce Springsteen. One of their biggest thrills was when The Boss joined them on stage.

Back in 2012, Joel Plaskett dropped by the Q107 Toronto studios to record a cover of one of his favourite Bruce Springsteen songs.

More recently, here is Jake Thistle from 2020. Ted Tocks Covers has shared his work on several occasions, most often with Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers tributes. Enjoy!

To summarize, in this writer’s opinion, ‘No Surrender’ is the tie that binds the entire ‘Born in the U.S.A.’ album. It is so important. Essential Bruce Springsteen, and in its naked acoustic form, there are few offerings that reflect Bruce Springsteen’s mindset as honestly.

Now on the street tonight the lights grow dim
The walls of my room are closing in
There’s a war outside still raging
You say it ain’t ours anymore to win
I want to sleep beneath
Peaceful skies in my lover’s bed
With a wide open country in my eyes
And these romantic dreams in my head”

Bruce has always had a way of sharing his philosophy in rhyming couplets. It’s a gift he has shared with us all.

To close out today’s feature, enjoy this version where Bruce shares the stage with Steven Van Zandt and the 2013 version of the E Street Band.

 They made a promise.

Over fifty years later they still both remember.

Fairytale of New York – I can see a better time when all our dreams come true. #MusicisLife #TedTocksCovers

When music fans talk about the great duets recorded through the years things get a little nostalgic. More often than not the conversation heads to the mainstream, or more aptly stated the middle of the road. That’s fine. Things tend to be safer there. Here, I am reminded of a quote from Neil Young commenting on how his commercial success was enjoyable financially, but the predictability bored him.

Heart of Gold’ put me in the middle of the road. Traveling there soon became a bore so I headed for the ditch.”

Neil Young

Today’s post will drag us through the ditch. Then we will stagger through the back alleys of New York City before spending the night in a Gotham drunk tank surrounded by a handful of people who will make us reflect on every mistake.

This is definitely a religious experience that exists on an earthly level. In the end, the bells will ring out, but somehow beyond Christmas day the future becomes uncertain.

We can always hope for this character at least, the powerful symbolism of the bells is one that foretells optimism.

‘Fairytale of New York’ was written by Jem Finer and Shane McGowan over a period of two years from 1985 to 1987 for the iconic London based band, the Pogues. It was written as a duet and when it came time to find the ideal partner for McGowan’s troubled character. Ultimately, they brought in Kirsty MacColl but a lot happened before this chapter unfolded. To put it bluntly, the process from start to completion was arduous. In fact, the original set of lyrics spoke of a sailor who was reflecting on his life at sea.

The common theme from the original version, to what we all know now as ‘Fairytale of New York’ is a deep contemplation of the future.

The connection from its earliest draft to what became the completed song was suggested by Jem Finer’s wife Marcia. She saw the potential for a heated conversation between a couple on Christmas Eve. As fate would have it, Finer was reading a novel called; you guessed it ‘A Fairy Tale of New York’ by J.P. Donleavy at the time. Everyone associated with the Pogues recalls the novel lying around the studio about the time the song was coming together.

The narrative of ‘Fairytale of New York’ follows the sordid affairs of an Irish immigrant in the Big Apple. He ends up in the drunk tank following a Christmas Eve drinking binge. While attempting to sleep off the poisonous effects, an elderly gentleman next to him laments his wasted life and points out that he fully expects this will likely be his last Christmas. He then begins to sing a passage of an old Irish song called ‘The Rare Old Mountain Dew’.

Now learned men as use the pen have writ the praises high
Of the sweet poitin from Ireland green, distilled from wheat and rye
Go away with your pills, it’ll cure all ills, be ye Pagan, Christian or Jew
Take off your coat and grease your throat with a bucketful of Mountain Dew”

Traditional Irish Folk Song

Enticing…But the ‘Fairy Tale of New York’ narrator gets the message and the rest of the song focuses on his own regrets.

He dreams of the love of his life with whom he shares, shall we say, a turbulent relationship.

He is cognizant enough of his wasted life that he manages to formulate this nasty exchange between he and his estranged partner.

The way it is introduced could be the opening scene of an epic film.

It was Christmas Eve, babe
In the drunk tank
An old man said to me
“Won’t see another one”
And then he sang a song
The Rare Old Mountain Dew
I turned my face away
And dreamed about you

Got on a lucky one
Came in eighteen to one
I’ve got a feeling
This year’s for me and you
So, Happy Christmas
I love you, baby
I can see a better time
When all our dreams come true

They’ve got cars big as bars, they’ve got rivers of gold
But the wind goes right through you, it’s no place for the old
When you first took my hand on a cold Christmas Eve
You promised me Broadway was waiting for me

You were handsome
You were pretty, Queen of New York City
When the band finished playing
They howled out for more
Sinatra was swinging
All the drunks, they were singing
We kissed on a corner
Then danced through the night

The boys of the NYPD choir
Were singing “Galway Bay”
And the bells were ringing out
For Christmas day

You’re a bum, you’re a punk
You’re an old slut on junk
Lying there almost dead
On a drip in that bed
You scumbag, you maggot
You cheap, lousy faggot
Happy Christmas, your arse
I pray God it’s our last

The boys of the NYPD choir
Still singing “Galway Bay”
And the bells are ringing out
For Christmas day

“I could have been someone”
Well, so could anyone
You took my dreams from me
When I first found you
I kept them with me, babe
I put them with my own
Can’t make it all alone
I’ve built my dreams around you

The boys of the NYPD choir
Still singing “Galway Bay”
And the bells are ringing out
For Christmas day”

Jem Finer and Shane MacGowan

It should be told that Jem Finer and Shane McGowan’s accounts related to the origin of ‘Fairytale of New York’ differ slightly, but the detail that Finer offers speaks to an interesting chronology.

Anecdotes such as the following reflection from Finer speak to the idea of the struggle he was having with pulling it all together.

I had written two songs complete with tunes, one had a good tune and crap lyrics, the other had the idea for ‘Fairytale’ but the tune was poxy, I gave them both to Shane and he gave it a Broadway melody, and there it was.”

Jem Finer

In the earliest incarnation of ‘Fairytale of New York’, Elvis Costello was working as producer. Shane MacGowan is on record as saying that it was Costello that offered a wager that claimed that Finer and MacGowan could never write a hit Christmas song.

When Finer shared the early draft that depicted a bickering couple, MacGowan was captured by the concept. In a twist of fate that speaks to the best presentations being timely, it was right around the end of the year so Christmas was fresh in MacGowan’s mind as he immersed himself in Finer’s lyrics.

I sat down, opened the sherry, got the peanuts out and pretended it was Christmas. It’s even called “A Fairy Tale of New York”, it’s quite sloppy, more like ‘A Pair of Brown Eyes’ than ‘Sally MacLennane’, but there’s also a ceildh bit in the middle which you can definitely dance to. Like a country and Irish ballad, but one you can do a brisk waltz to, especially when you’ve got about three of these [drinks] inside you… But the song itself is quite depressing in the end, it’s about these old Irish-American Broadway stars who are sitting round at Christmas talking about whether things are going okay.”

Shane MacGowan

By January of 1986, the Pogues were ready to record and they brought in Cait O’Riordan to act as Shane MacGowan’s partner. Interestingly, O’Riordan was known to be Elvis Costello’s romantic partner at about this time, and for several years following, but the relationship was severed in 2002 due to O’Riordan’s struggles with a series of mental health issues that were only exacerbated by her alcoholism. It should be noted here that she has been sober since 2007.

Speaking to this chapter of the song’s development, I was pleased to find this early demo of ‘Fairytale of New York’. Under Costello’s tutelage, at the time the Pogues were calling the song ‘Christmas Eve in the Drunk Tank’.

Something about the perceived negativity of the title didn’t sit well with Shane MacGowan. Never too concerned with the commercial success of his work, he knew that a song with that title would not draw the listener’s interest. It lacked any sense of intrigue. Despite the obvious power of the performance the song was shelved for a period; partially due to the internal debate and also because MacGowan became bed-ridden with double pneumonia.

From here, a combination of things happened. Caught up between his relationship with O’Riordan and a deteriorating dynamic with the Pogues, Elvis Costello stepped away from his producer role, giving way to the accomplished Steve Lillywhite. With Costello gone, so too was the female accompaniment to MacGowan. This combined with Steve Lillywhite’s coming in and declaring the Pogues/O’Riordan collaboration as ‘not fully realized’ added to the uncertainty that the song would ever be released.

There really is something to be said about the drive to perfection and the heights a song can achieve when it is introduced to a new set of ears.  

All of these hurdles only added to the Pogues determination to make Fairytale of New York’ happen.

Perhaps the most important detail that led to ‘Fairytale of New York’ actually being recorded at all was the impending Pogues U.S. tour. This would be the Pogues first in the United States, and fortuitously it included a date in New York City, a locale that had long since fascinated both MacGowan and Finer.

Imagine a 1000-piece jigsaw puzzle spread out before you in pieces, and then close your eyes. Now what if after opening your eyes up again consider that one fateful evening could allow all the pieces to magically come together and serve to relay the story you have been trying to tell for so long. This is pretty much what happened.

The visit to New York City helped the songwriters modify the initial scene they were describing. They realized as much as they wanted to offer the story from the perspective of their native Ireland, they had not really captured the nuance of the city that never sleeps. Being there, changed everything. Backstage following their New York show the Pogues were visited by filmmaker Peter Dougherty and acclaimed actor Matt Damon. Both would play integral roles in the subsequent video of ‘Fairytale of New York’. Inspired by the Sergio Leone film ‘Once Upon a Time in America’, Shane MacGowan wrote the piano introduction to ‘Fairytale in New York’.

As a result of this injection of life ‘Fairytale of New York’ was back on track. With Steve Lillywhite at the helm the Pogues entered Abbey Road Studios in March of 1987 with a plan to have Shane MacGowan sing both the male and female parts.

Listen and you can clearly see that Shane is begging for a muse.

Someone suggested that the vocal track might be perfect for someone close to Steve Lillywhite…His wife, Kirsty MacColl. Lillywhite was on board with this suggestion. He took the music and MacGowan’s best demo home with him and asked Kirsty to lay down a new guide vocal for ‘Fairytale in New York’. When he returned to the studio, the Pogues were blown away.

It all sounds so easy now, but this took about two years to come to fruition.

Kirsty knew exactly the right measure of viciousness and femininity and romance to put into it and she had a very strong character and it came across in a big way… In operas, if you have a double aria, it’s what the woman does that really matters. The man lies, the woman tells the truth.”

Shane MacGowan

Another in a long line of fascinating facts related to this timeless song is that MacGowan and MacColl did not sing it together in the studio. The more one sits and listens to this recording, the more startling this remains. You would swear they were side by side as they carried out this dialogue in song.

Kirsty MacColl died on this day in 2000 when she was struck by a speedboat in Mexico while attempting to save her sons from the oncoming craft.

Here are the Pogues together with Kirsty MacColl on Top of the Pops in 1987.

It’s like a one act play that leaves the viewer hanging.

So, what did ‘Fairytale of New York’ mean to Shane MacGowan? Here is his summation.

It was a happy time for the group. It’s our ‘Bohemian Rhapsody’. I was very grateful to Kirsty. I don’t think it would have been such a big hit without her contribution.”

Shane MacGowan

An apt comparison, I say.

Among the seemingly endless passages that heap praise upon this brilliant piece of music, this review by Helen Brown of The Daily Telegraph. She captures the mood; the spirit and the sociological implications of this timeless song.

In careening wildly through a gamut of moods from maudlin to euphoric, sentimental to profane, mud-slinging to sincerely devoted in the space of four glorious minutes – it’s seemed perfectly suited to Christmas – a time which highlights the disparity between the haves and have nots around the world. Those of us lucky enough to spend the day with friends and families by a cosy fire with a full stomach think of the lonely, the homeless and the hungry. As MacColl and MacGowan’s dialogue descends from the ecstasy of their first kiss into an increasingly vitriolic argument their words puts the average family’s seasonal bickering into perspective. “You’re a bum you’re a punk/ You’re an old slut on junk…” The song’s row ends with an expression of love and hope (against all the odds) as MacGowan’s character promises MacColl’s that, far from wrecking her dreams he has kept them with his own “Can’t make it all alone,” he pleads, “I’ve built my dreams around you.”

Helen Brown

I say again; if ever there was a song that could form the basis of a feature film.

Perhaps there is some irony to the fact that Shane MacGowan was born on Christmas Day? The driving force behind the presentation of ‘Fairytale of New York’ could feel the significance of the message within the song and the perceived hopelessness of the character’s plight. There are dreams and promises; a clear desire to be better. He has built his dream around one person, but he can’t get past his own fatal flaw. Through the honesty and vulnerability presented in this song, a global popularity developed.

It’s entirely appropriate that Shane Patrick Lysaght MacGowan was born on Christmas Day because his celebrated song Fairytale Of New York seems to be just about everybody’s favourite festive piece of music. The 1987 song by the Pogues – once censored by the BBC for its raw language – was announced as the most-played Christmas song of the century by music licensing body PPL.”

Martin Chilton

An eternal truth exists. Everybody loves an underdog. Shane was the voice.

Rivers of tears were shed when it was announced that Shane MacGowan died on November 30 of pneumonia. This was the culmination of several years of poor health and efforts to overcome his demons. His devoted wife Victoria was by his side.

He was just so full of love and I’m feeling so much love now from him that I don’t think he can go away. I don’t think that love can go away.”

Victoria Mary Clarke

If a tribute show is ever put together to honour the memory and contribution of Shane MacGowan I would submit Christy Moore as the perfect performer to lead off the festivities. For today. I will have to humbly submit one of his cover versions to open up a nice list of quality tributes to this song that stirs the soul no matter who is playing. This is live from 1991.

Listen as he concludes the story with;

Hey Shane! I love you too baby.”

Christy Moore

Moving forward to 2000, enjoy this dramatic offering from Ronan Keating and Moya Brennan. This is simply beautiful.

A couple of years later in 2002, and long after he was asked to leave the Pogues for his drinking issues and troubling behavior, Shane MacGowan’s continued to play with his band known as the Popes. This live performance is essential because it includes his mother, Therese. They are introduced by host Pat Kenny. What strikes me about this performance is Therese is dealing with a little bit of stage fright but Shane brings her through. The song ends with the pair dancing together. That piano introduction gets me every time.

In an effort to mix up the styles as well as sharing an interesting cast of characters who have dabbled in this masterpiece, I offer Alan Doyle of Great Big Sea along with Russell Crowe and Hugh Jackman. This is from the NYC Indoor Garden Party back in 2012.

I could have been someone, but so could anyone.”

Jem Finer and Shane MacGowan

Continuing with big names who honour the tradition, here is Florence and the Machine with Billy Bragg.  I love the approach Florence and the Machine brings to everything they do, but when you combine their style to the masterful delivery of Billy Bragg, magic ensues. Listen to that harp. This is a little subdued, but it still commands your attention.

In 2017, Ed Sheeran and Anne-Marie combined to present this passionate effort. Ed is good but truth be told, this covers kicks it up a notch when Anne-Marie joins in. I love this version. Top marks for the traditional Irish band that offers their talents. They all come together to combine ‘Fairytale of New York’ with a ‘Jingle Bells’ outro.

There is a level of camaraderie in this rendition of ‘Fairytale of New York’ in an episode of ‘Live from Here’. Here is Jeff Tweedy along with a host of friends closing their set in December of 2017, much to the fans’ delight. Tweedy is joined by Chris Thile, The Staves, Sarah Jarosz, Punch Brothers, Rich Dwarsky and Ted Poor.

Are there any Jon Bon Jovi fans out there? This is a quality cover from 2020. This is from ‘A Jon Bon Jovi Christmas’. It seems Jon is tapping into his never-ending mission to alleviate homelessness and mental health issues. I admire his philanthropic efforts and his genuine desire to make the world a better place. While critics piled on, I submit this as one of the best things he has ever done.

Closer to Christmas in 2020 when people were coping with challenges related to the Covid 19 pandemic Puddles Pity Party created this beautiful cover of ‘Fairytale of New York’ with the incredibly talented and captivating Storm Large. Here is the stunning result.

Let’s share a cup of coffee with Vance Joy and listen to him play ‘Fairytale of New York’ on the ukulele. I love this version.

To conclude the covers portion of today’s feature, let’s say that when I saw that Jason and Travis Kelce were involved in a modified version of ‘Fairytale of New York’ called ‘Fairytale of Philadelphia’ I was somewhat dubious, but I took the time to listen and I was pleasantly surprised. The Kelce Brothers take it to Broad Street. It works…Listen…Taylor Swift would be proud.

This was released in mid-November of 2023. Just two weeks before the sad news of Shane MacGowan’s death hit the news cycle. Ideally, this cover version will expose many new fans to the work of the Pogues.

Before we move on and enjoy our day, let’s go to an Irish Wake. This tribute was offered at Shane MacGowan’s funeral last week. What a moment. This eulogy of sorts featured Glen Hansard and Lisa O’Neill on vocals. Ireland’s President Michal D. Higgins was just a few feet away. If we could all be sent off in such a spirited way.

Within a week of Shane MacGowan’s death ‘Fairytale of New York’ made its way to #1 in Ireland. With this success the Pogues re-issued the song as a 7-inch single and announced that proceeds from sales would go to Dublin Simon Community which is and organization devoted to fighting homelessness. This was a mission close to Shane MacGowan’s heart.

‘Fairytale of New York’ became a Christmas song despite the fact that to many, it presents as everything that could be construed as anti-Christmas. Somehow in an effort to write a song about lost hope; through a troubling narrative the underlying message has resonated for over three decades.

Any semblance of optimism shines through in the chorus as the boys of the NYPD choir are singing ‘Galway Bay’. Listen as Dolores Keane takes us out.

As long as the music is playing there is hope.

Here, the voices are singing and the bells are ringing, and a world moves on holding on to every reason to believe.

Cheers Shane!