Admittedly, today’s feature song has been selected as a means to introduce the theme of the post.
On this day 50 years ago the guys that were ‘Playing in the Band’ put on a concert for the ages at Watkins Glen Grand Prix Raceway just outside of Watkins Glen, New York.
Before we go there, let’s spend a few minutes at the Hammerstein Ballroom in the Manhattan Center, New York City. The recording that opened this post is from April 6, 1971. It was recorded for the Grateful Dead album ‘Skull and Roses’. ‘Playing in the Band appeared as the closing track on side one of this double live offering that became the Grateful Dead’s first gold album.
Somehow, this seems appropriate because the Dead experience was always best captured live.
Now let’s head upstate to Watkins Glen.
How much?
Ten bucks!
Let me get this straight…$10 to see The Band, The Allman Brothers Band and the Grateful Dead?
Yep!
Count me in.
Well not exactly. For me that was a story to be told a little further down the line, but on this day 50 years ago, these three monster bands got together to play an epic one-day concert at Watkins Glen Raceway for an estimated 600,000 music fans. The Guinness Book of World Records called Watkins Glen the “largest audience for a pop festival.”
Promoters; Shelly Finkel and Jim Koplik got the idea for this concert extravaganza after they brought the Grateful Dead to Hartford, Connecticut in July of 1972. It just happened that Dickey Betts, Berry Oakley and Jaimoe from the Allman Brothers Band showed up and jammed with the Dead on ‘Not Fade Away’, ‘Goin’ Down the Road Feelin’ Bad’, ‘Hey Bo Diddley’ and ‘Johnny B. Goode’ to close the show.
When they floated the idea to the two bands they were greeted with an enthusiastic response. Finkel and Koplik asked the Grateful Dead and the Allman Brothers Band who else they would like to play with, and the response was unanimous.
The answer was, The Band.
Planning began for the show that would take place in the summer of 1973. Depending on your perspective, the project represented either modest expectations or the loftiest of dreams.
They settled on the site and drew on the expertise of the legendary Bill Graham for the stage design and sound. Ticket prices were set at just $10. The goal was established at about 100,000 people. Promotion would be focused on the Eastern seaboard of the United States and along the Canadian border from Toronto to Montreal.
Here is Jim Koplik, briefly commenting on what transpired.
Who can explain it. We spent less than $30,000 on advertising and we wound up selling 150,000 tickets at $10 each. But we never dreamed we’d have this many people. I guess they just found the concept appealing — a day of music in the country.”
Jim Koplik
When Koplik speaks of ‘this many people’ he is referring to the fact that when the concert began well over half a million people had descended upon the concert site. Music fans arrived more than 24 hours early and they kept on coming.
Like the song says…
Some folks trust to reason
Robert Hunter, Bob Weir and Mickey Hart
Others trust to might
I don’t trust to nothing
But I know it come out right
Say it once again now
Oh, I hope you understand
When it’s done and over
Lord, a man is just a man
Playing
Playing in the band
Daybreak
Daybreak on the land
Some folks look for answers
Others look for fights
Some folks up in treetops
Just look to see the sights
I can tell your future
Look what’s in your hand
But I can’t stop for nothing
I’m just playing in the band
Playing
Playing in the band
Daybreak
Daybreak on the land
Standing on a tower
World at my command
You just keep a turning
While I’m playing in the band
If a man among you
Got no sin upon his hand
Let him cast a stone at me
For playing in the band
Playing
Playing in the band
Daybreak
Daybreak on the land
Playing
Playing in the band
Daybreak daybreak on the land”
Much like Woodstock, Watkins Glen became a free concert. Like Blind Willie McTell said:
I’m goin’ to the country
Blind Willie McTell
Baby, do you want to go?
‘Cause if you can’t make it, baby
Your sister Lucille said she wanna go
And I sure will take her”
Somehow, it all worked out just fine.
Even the soundchecks became epic experiences. When all the bands arrived the day before, Robbie Robertson suggested that they take a soundcheck. Because well over 200,000 people had already made their way through the backroads and secret trails that led to the venue these sets turned into mini performances. The Band encouraged audience participation during ‘The Night they Drove Old Dixie Down’. Rick Danko sang ‘Raining in My Heart’ by Buddy Holly.
“More piano”
Man! This voice is missed.
The Allman Brothers Band played ‘Ramblin Man’ from ‘Brothers and Sisters’ and ‘One Way Out’.
The Grateful Dead jammed for an hour and a half. Here is a portion of their trademark experimentation which was released on ‘So Many Roads – 1965-1995’.
This portion was highlighted by ‘Eyes of the World’ which had only been unveiled to Deadheads in February of 1973.
Here is another section of the jam experience that morphed into ‘Wharf Rat’. Just imagine being there?
And we haven’t even got to concert day…
At exactly noon on Saturday July 28, Bill Graham got up on the stage, and like he had done hundreds of times before, he introduced the Grateful Dead.
From Marin County to Watkins Glen, the Grateful Dead”
Bill Graham
The Dead’s first set opened with ‘Bertha’ and appropriately closed with ‘Playing in the Band’. This was the beginning of a legendary set of music that saw them play for four hours in the blazing heat. It should be noted here, that the Grateful Dead had lost their bandmate and dear friend Ron ‘Pigpen’ McKernan in March of 1973.
Following the Grateful Dead at about 6 pm was The Band who played a fragmented two- hour set. It was divided by a wicked thunderstorm. The interlude jam that connected their portion of the show became known as ‘Too Wet to Work’. It was inspired by Garth Hudson who performed a memorable version of his standard experimental keyboard expose know as ‘Genetic Method’.
This led into the classic Band song ‘Chest Fever’ which brought the massive audience back to life.
The Watkins Glen expanse had turned into a swamp, but the 600,000 music fans were completely unphased.
Levon stated that Garth Hudson’s monstrous performance at Watkin’s Glen on this day would be;
Forever burned into my memory.”
Levon Helm
Another song that The Band weaved into their set was ‘W.S. Walcott Medicine Show’.
I was reminded of the lyrics which managed to effectively capture the scene.
When your arms are empty, got nowhere to go
Robbie Robertson
Come on out and catch this show
There’ll be saints and sinners, you’ll see losers and winners
All kinds of people you might want to know
Once you get it, you can’t forget it
W.S. Walcott Medicine Show”
See what I mean?
At 10 pm the Allman Brothers Band took the stage. This was the band’s opportunity to unveil ‘Brothers and Sisters’ before the adoring audience. This is marketing at its finest. Similar to the Grateful Dead, the Allman Brothers Band was going through a period of profound loss. As we all know the ‘Brothers’ had lost Duane Allman in the fall of 1971 and one year later Berry Oakley died under eerily similar circumstances. The band replaced these two seemingly irreplaceable talents with the keyboard prowess of the great Chuck Leavell, and the grooving bass skills of Lamar Williams
The Allman Brothers played a thunderous three hour set that left the throng in a frenzy. They played all their hits, and jammed into the night. One of the many highlights of their performance was ‘Come and Go Blues’ which would be released in 1976 on ‘Wipe the Windows, Check the Oil, Dollar Gas’
For a sense of the experience, here is a soundboard recording of the four-hour Dead set which features members of The Band and the Allman Brothers Band during a one-hour encore that featured ‘Not Fade Away’, ‘Mountain Jam’ and ‘Johnny B. Goode’.
In the book ‘Aquarius Rising’ author Robert Santelli offered this mindboggling analysis of the significance of this extraordinary Watkins Glen concert.
“Many historians claimed that the Watkins Glen event was the largest gathering of people in the history of the United States. In essence, that meant that on July 28, one out of every 350 people living in America at the time was listening to the sounds of rock at the New York state racetrack. Considering that most of those who attended the event hailed from the Northeast, and that the average age of those present was approximately seventeen to twenty-four, close to one out of every three young people from Boston to New York, was at the festival”
An event of such proportions would be unfathomable in today’s grossly divided world for many reasons, but on this day fifty years ago ‘The Music Never Stopped’.
Couldn’t resist sharing this Bob Weir/ John Barlow gem.
Speaking of Bob Weir and today’s symbolic feature song, ‘Playing in the Band’, the legendary rhythm guitar wizard offered his own version of this song on his debut solo album ‘Ace’. The personnel actually makes ‘Ace’ resemble a Dead album but Weir’s version is unique. The most salient difference is the backing vocals offered by Donna Jean Godchaux.
The original Grateful Dead version has only Bill Kreutzmann on drums and Donna wasn’t around yet to contribute vocals. For this listener at least, count me in on the 1971 original which was written by master lyricist Robert Hunter along with Bob Weir and Mickey Hart.
Now let’s explore a host of covers and tributes of ‘Playing in the Band’ through the years. I will share these in rapid succession.
Twenty-five years ago, Bob Weir, Phil Lesh and Mickey Hart assembled a quality group of musicians and appropriately called them The Other Ones. Other members included, the impossibly talented honorary Grateful Dead member Bruce Hornsby on piano and keyboards as well as Dave Ellis on saxophone, Steve Kimock on guitar, Mark Karan on guitar and John Molo on drums.
This collective released ‘The Strange Remain’ which was a gathering of some highlights from their Furthur Festival tour throughout 1998.
From the ‘and now for something completely different’ department, here is Punk is Dead from 2010. Time to wake up. This is a blast.
Among the countless musical ensembles that produce tributes to the work of the Grateful Dead, few rival the prowess and remarkable interpretation of Joe Russo’s Almost Dead. Enjoy this epic rendition of ‘Playing in the Band’ from Capitol Theater in Port Chester, New York.
This is an important cover for several reasons. Here is Phish with Bob Weir in 2016. On the surface, this is a ton of fun, but it becomes more intriguing when we recall that in 2015 when the Grateful Dead played their brief ‘Fare Thee Well’ 50th anniversary tour, it was Trey Anastasio of Phish that the Grateful Dead selected to be their lead guitarist. Add to this the fact that although music festivals at Watkins Glen were relatively rare, it was back in 2011 that Phish played four consecutive shows at this venue. Phish performed similar runs in 2015 and 2018.
Almost done; this time from last year. This is the Dark Star Orchestra. Another in a long line of quality musicians who got on the bus and delivered the music to anyone who wanted to listen along the way.
Earlier this month Dead and Company featuring Bob Weir and Mickey Hart as the only remaining original members played their final show. Enjoy the ‘Playing in in the Band’ reprise along with Oteil Burbridge on bass, Jeff Chimenti on keyboards and Jay Lane on drums. John Mayer continued his personal mission to pay tribute to Jerry Garcia in spirit and style.
As a concluding statement, my introduction to the live Grateful Dead experience occurred a little over a decade after the Watkins Glen date. It was the first day of summer in 1984 at Canada’s Wonderland. The bill included The Band, minus Robbie Robertson of course, and the Grateful Dead. The show was part of the Seva Benefit series. Seva was founded by Hugh Romney, also known as Wavy Gravy. The Seva Foundation’s mission is ‘a world free of blindness’. Through the work of Seva, local eye care providers have developed self-sustaining eye programs around the world. Although over a billion people live with unaddressed vision impairments and hundreds of millions need ongoing eyecare, over 90% of all of these impairments can be treated or prevented. For over four decades Seva has provided eyeglasses, treatment and other eye care services to over 50 million people in more than 20 countries.
Seva is a Sanskrit word meaning “selfless service to others”.
The ticket was just $10.
The best $10 I ever spent.
Over a decade had past and the lineups for the bands were slightly different, but the experience, while scaled down significantly from Watkins Glen was still formative.
All these years later I can still close my eyes and picture the scene.
Much like the thousands of people who still post their Watkins Glen memories all these years later. Here is just one.
I arrived very early, and had a spot very close to the stage. The soundcheck the night before the actual show, was tremendous in itself. The Dead were at their very best, definitely more on point than the following day at noon. It was hot and insufferably humid, not the best for playing stringed instruments! There was a lot of Ramrod’s notorious “White Lightning” acid around the grounds, and mescaline as well. It seemed everybody was tripping. The Band, though interrupted by a flash rainstorm, was transcendent.”
Paul
Transcendent!
That’s the word.
You must be logged in to post a comment.