Back in the early ‘80s, I was a student attending Acton High School. At the time, three radio stations were earnestly vying for the ear of the lucrative Southern Ontario market. If you favoured new wave, CFNY was the choice. Being more of a hard rock, progressive rock and British invasion guy, I gravitated to CHUM-FM and Q107. By the mid ‘80s CHUM-FM went off the rails, so I ended up at the ‘Mighty Q’ for many years. As much as Q107 opened the door to so much music of the past, at one time they also did a phenomenal job of providing exposure for up-and-coming rock bands. They offered a solid mix. Numerous Toronto area bands cite Q107 as an essential catalyst to their success.
Suitably, one such band was Toronto. This act formed in the late ‘70s and drew a significant amount of attention with their cutting-edge sound. Their ace in the hole was dynamic vocalist, Annie ‘Holly’ Woods who reminded astute listeners of Pat Benatar. Just an observation, but it seems that what lovers of music tend to do when they hear something new, is immediately aim to create favourable comparisons to an artist they like (or don’t like), and then form an opinion. This is one example of how musical camps were formed. Forty years ago, those houses were quite rigid and people were not so open to stepping outside the walls. Fortunately for Toronto, this created an camp of devout listeners for the short period that they were active.
They are remembered fondly.
The band’s lineup was a bit of a revolving door, but the key members were Woods and guitarist Brian Allen. They were joined by guitarist/backing vocalist Sheron Alton, keyboard player Scott Kreyer, bassist Nick Costello and drummer Jimmy Fox. In 1980, Toronto released their debut album ‘Lookin’ for Trouble’ which featured ‘Even the Score’. This song generated positive exposure on Q107. It takes me back.
One year later, Toronto released their follow up album ‘Head On’. Here is the title track.
See what I mean? It is good stuff. It definitely takes any listener back to that era of music. Toronto was fresh, and they were a developing local success story.
Behind the scenes Toronto was enduring dissension within the ranks. Their rhythm section disintegrated with the departure of Costello and Fox. They were replaced with Garry Lalonde and Barry Connors. The newly formed sextet headed into the studio and recorded what would become their most popular album, ‘Get It on Credit’ in 1982. This album yielded one of today’s feature songs.
‘Your Daddy Don’t Know’ went all the way to #5 in Canada, and it even penetrated the United States market, reaching #77. The song was written by Geoff Iwamoto and Michael Roth. Holly Woods delivery was emphatic. It hit you right between the eyes.
With all this chart success, and some high-profile Juno nominations, Toronto was poised for a meteoric rise, but as mentioned, internal dissent was an issue. One of the core problems stemmed from the song selection for ‘Get It on Credit’. This becomes the big story of today’s post.
Listen to a song that we all know called ‘What About Love’.
This was written by Sheron Alton, Brian Allen and producer Jim Vallance as part of the ‘Get It on Credit’ sessions. As the story goes, Toronto recorded about fifteen solid tracks for this important third album, but only ten made the cut. This infuriated Alton and Allen, who opted to leave the band. Barry Connors was close behind. Truth be told, he didn’t even play the drums on ‘What About Love’. He offered the kit to Jim Vallance since he was an integral part in writing the song.
This set up leads to the bigger story. Here it is, in the words of Jim Vallance.
Brian and Sheron had a small studio in their basement. One night they invited me to their home for dinner. Afterwards we went downstairs and wrote a song based on a title that’d been kicking around in my head for a month or more … “What About Love”. I envisioned those three words sung on one note, like John Lennon did on “All You Need Is Love”. That’s all I had, but they liked the idea. I don’t want to say it was easy, because writing songs is never easy, but “What About Love” came together very quickly. It only took two or three hours to complete, with each of us contributing equal portions of music and lyric. I came away thinking we’d really “clicked” as a songwriting team, and I thought the song was more than good.”
Jim Vallance
This tells the story of the creation of ‘What About Love’ and it speaks to how it was rejected by a band that were at a crossroads, but how did it end up in the hands of music legends?
Once again, here is Jim Vallance.
It took a while to connect the dots, to get the whole story. I knew that Solid Gold, Toronto’s label, had gone bankrupt, but I didn’t know Solid Gold’s catalogue had been acquired by ATV Music. ATV’s Canadian publisher Michael McCarty took the time to listen to every song in the Solid Gold catalogue, including unreleased demo recordings. “What About Love” caught his ear and he sent a copy to Don Grierson, who in turn played the song for Heart’s producer, Ron Nevison.”
Jim Vallance
Here is Ron Nevison’s recollection of ‘What About Love’. As you read, take note of the fact that even the Wilson sisters were divided at first.
I remember specifically being up at Nancy’s house in Snohomish, Washington, rehearsing, and when I played that song, Nancy left the room. She wasn’t happy with that song at first for Heart. They hated the treatment and production of the demo, and I think it was more the vocal they hated. Because the vocal in the demo was so wimpy, and I said, ‘Listen, here’s the way it’s gonna be: I am not going to force you to do any song. But also, when you listen to a demo, I don’t want you to listen to someone’s wimped-out vocal, because you guys are the greatest singers in the entire fuckin’ rock world. So, I want you to think of this demo as musical notes on paper. Pretend I handed you a lyric and music sheet, and you’re gonna play it as a band, and if you can’t make it your own, I’m not gonna make you do it’. And suddenly it came alive, and there was a lesson there. A producer can listen through and past that. I was only listening to melodies and notes, not to vocal performances and production. A lot of people aren’t capable of seeing past that, but Don Grierson was and I was, and I didn’t have to make Heart do it. They started playing it, and once Ann and Nancy heard it on tape, the went, ‘Oh … okay’. It became much more their song by the time we’d gone from pre-production to proper recording. I’ll never forget the day that their managers came into the studio, right after I cut the basic track at the Record Plant in L.A., which was just a rhythm guitar, keyboard and vocal on it. They flipped out over it, and the girls were almost over the moon, everybody was, at how good it had turned out. And I hadn’t even mixed it yet. So, the lesson there is always jump to conclusions slowly.”
Ron Nevison
As a result of Ron Nevison’s perseverance, ‘What About Love’ by Heart became a hit single on both rock and pop charts, selling over five million copies within a year of its release.
Here is Heart’s version of ‘What About Love’. This track includes Mickey Thomas and Grace Slick of Starship on backing vocals.
Twenty years after it was originally recorded, Toronto released their ‘original’ version of ‘What About Love’ as part of their compilation album ‘Toronto: The Greatest Hits’.
In 2021, ‘What About Love’ was inducted into the Canadian Songwriters Hall of Fame. Yet another fascinating footnote that speaks to the fact so much of Heart’s success has Canadian roots.
The revolving door for Toronto continued. This saw Garry Lalonde move on to the band Honeymoon Suite. You can see him playing bass on ‘Feel It Again’ which was part of the band’s acclaimed second album ‘The Big Prize’. Again, classic CanCon from the ‘80s.
Barry Connors went on to become the drummer for Coney Hatch, but by the time he arrived the band had seen their best days.
Bringing things full circle, here is ‘Your Daddy Don’t Know’ by New Pornographers. This cover was part of the soundtrack for the movie ‘FUBAR’.
Over the last forty years a lot of water has flowed beneath the bridge. The Canadian music scene is highly regarded the world over. There are so many bands and artists of renown. One can almost imagine it in tiers. Looking back, I see Toronto, firmly ensconced on the third tier of this ladder. They are not among the greats, but they definitely showed many acts to come that hard work and dedication to their craft could be a gateway to local, national and even international success. A short time after Toronto emerged as a strong act with a dynamic female lead, many other similar bands grabbed the torch. Along with a list of worthy hits and one ground-breaking international single, albeit not initially released by them; this is their legacy.
They were not quite pioneers, but they certainly helped to blaze a trail.