Writing Ted Tocks Covers has taken me to thousands of places without ever leaving my little corner of the kitchen where I do 90% of my writing. Typically, with each day of writing I begin by looking out into the darkness. My eyes adjust, and slowly the moonlight reveals the shadow of the back fence and the faint form of the trees in the forest behind my house. As the clock ticks and daylight takes over from the mystery of night, I am frequently distracted by the rabbits searching for whatever traces of food they can find or the squirrels frolicking before chasing each other up a tree then jumping acrobatically from branch to branch. It’s nature’s circus. Always entertaining, and it doesn’t cost a cent.
Today my soundtrack is ‘A Trick of the Tail’ the remarkable seventh album by Genesis which was released 50 years ago today. For this album the range of inspiration was wide and the obvious connections only begin with The Beatles, Led Zeppelin and Santana before heading off into the classical realm.
The fact that such a stunning collection of music could have been created during a period of transition for Genesis is testament to their greatness. ‘A Trick of the Tail’ was created in the wake of Peter Gabriel’s departure. Gabriel had let his bandmates know his intentions during the ‘Lamb Lies Down on Broadway’ tour. Numerous personal reasons had led to this decision and while Tony Banks, Phil Collins, Steve Hackett and Mike Rutherford were disappointed that Gabriel quit, they were not surprised.
Stories of the band’s search for a replacement represent a fascinating chapter in the Genesis history.
We all know how it ends and the journey took them to a familiar place.
Before we move on, here is Genesis drummer, Phil Collins taking on the lead vocal role on ‘For Absent Friends’ earlier in the decade.
Looking back at days of four instead of two.
Years seem so few (four instead of two).
Heads bent in prayer
For friends not there”
This song about aging and the passage of time appeared on ‘Nursery Cryme’ in 1971.
Despite the fact Peter Gabriel’s departure was hanging over them, the band was determined to move forward. While auditions proved fruitless, they had gathered an impressive array of lyrics and music.
‘A Trick of the Tail’ became an effort to prove to fans and critics that the show would and could go on. What is so intriguing is that during this time there was so much going on.
It all began with ‘Squonk’, a stunning piece of music which presented Tony Banks and Mike Rutherford as the primary composers. Tony Banks, who was perhaps Gabriel’s best friend in the band had accumulated a fair bit of material because he had been contemplating a solo album. At the same time, Genesis guitarist, Steve Hackett who was also searching for his own autonomy within the Genesis family was writing material for what would become ‘Voyage of the Acolyte’. Here is that recording. Essential listening for any lover of the ‘prog’ genre and a focused glimpse at the guitar prowess of Steve Hackett.
This is an important stop on the musical timeline that led to ‘A Trick of the Tail’ because it did feature contributions from Phil Collins and Mike Rutherford.
Rehearsals for ‘A Trick of the Tail’ began in the summer of 1975 in a basement studio in the west London town of Acton.
While all of this was happening Genesis placed a cryptic ad in Melody Maker that depicted a band that was searching for;
A singer for a Genesis-type group”
The ad drew the attention of approximately 400 people who cynically could have been accused of pretending to be Peter Gabriel. When word got out that Gabriel was leaving, the music press and fans alike predicted that Genesis was doomed. Prompted by an article penned by Peter Gabriel himself which was headlined “Out, Angels Out”, the word spread. This piece is so well written that it would not do Peter Gabriel justice to simply isolate a few sentences or one paragraph. It is well worth reading.
This was a different time. Articles in publications like ‘Melody Maker’ drew thousands.
Gabriel Out of Genesis!”
Chris Webb perpetuated the doom and gloom among the legion of Genesis devotees.
No longer will Peter startle his fans with apparitions, kinetic structures and theatrical trickery of every description…”
Among the hundreds of audition tapes were offers from Nick Lowe, Allen Clarke of the Hollies, Mick Rogers of Manfred Mann’s Earth Band and Mike Strickland.
Accounts from this time suggest it was Mike Strickland who came the closest, but it was quickly determined that his voice was in the wrong key for the majority of Genesis material. Audition tapes do exist and try as he did, it was clearly an ordeal, as suggested by Mike Rutherford.
It was in completely the wrong key. The poor guy battled through it, but it was never going to work.”
Band conversations saw Phil Collins floating the idea of becoming an instrumental act.
For a time, I thought we’d carry on as a four-piece without any singing.”
This was swiftly rejected because they all agreed it would be a little too introspective to be financially sustainable
We kept writing songs. But after a while we realized they’d get a bit boring without any vocals.”
So, the band played on. For what was to become ‘A Trick of the Tail’ Phil Collins brought up the name of producer, David Hentschel who went back to the group’s ‘Nursery Cryme album. Most recently Hentschel had been the engineer on the Elton John masterpiece ‘Goodbye Yellow Brick Road’. Recording for ‘A Trick of the Tail’ began in October. On a side note, Peter Gabriel visited the studio and was impressed by what he heard.
And still, those who were asking the band were told that there was no singer…
Despite this glaring fact Genesis was churning out the material, lyrics and all. Peter Gabriel’s validation confirmed what they already knew. ‘Ripples’ was written by Mike Rutherford with Phil’s vocal ability in mind. Still reluctant. Phil complied and declared that once the demo was complete, he would teach Peter Gabriel’s replacement.
Tony Banks shines again and Mike Rutherford’s lyrics which are laid down over his beautiful 12 string guitar playing describe the aging process and the helplessness we face against the passage of time.
Sail away, away
Ripples never come back
Gone to the other side
Look into the pool, the ripples never come back, come back
Dive to the bottom and go to the top
To see where they have gone
They’ve gone to the other side”
Wisdom beyond his years.
Then came ‘Squonk’. For this prog rock masterpiece, Mike Rutherford was influenced by Argentinian writer Jorge Luis Borges’ ‘Book of Imaginary Beings’. Tony Banks looked toward industry peer John Paul Jones’s contribution to Led Zeppelin’s timeless track, ‘Kashmir’ as a guiding light. Meanwhile, Phil himself was inspired by John Bonham and ‘When the Levee Breaks’ for his drum track.
All in all you are a very dying race
Placing trust upon a cruel world
You never had the things you thought you should have had
And you’ll not get them now
And all the while in perfect time
Your tears are falling on the ground”
This piece was written almost entirely without Steve Hackett who added his guitar parts after being captivated by what his bandmates had composed. All of this foreshadowed the band’s future.
Ultimately, it was Phil Collins’s wife Andrea who told him he was more than capable of becoming the full-time vocalist for Genesis.
This sentiment was reinforced in hindsight, by Phil’s friend Bill Bruford who always suspected what would happen. Here he recalls a conversation with Collins;
He said something like, ‘They’re all bloody useless – I can sing better than they can,’”
Phil got the job.
The rest is history. A steady flow of classic post-Peter Gabriel Genesis tracks had already begun, and they would continue at a prolific pace.
On the outside many were sceptical but Genesis was unphased. They just started recording and knocked one song off after another. They were energized by what ended up becoming an example of addition by subtraction. Any doubts were quickly dispelled.
From here we will run through a song by song look back at what remains of ‘A Trick of the Tail’.
With ‘Dance on a Volcano’ Genesis was sending a message to every critic and fan who thought they could not go on without Peter Gabriel. It is a sensational album opener. The usually understated Mike Rutherford was pleased with this statement song.
It embodied all that Genesis did well,”
If you didn’t tune in with the full album shared at the outset of this post, then check it out here, or by all mean listen again…
One glaringly obvious characteristic of ‘A Trick of the Tail’ is the fact that clues to Steve Hackett’s eventual departure were beginning to break through the cracks. A major change in the typical Genesis process saw the band move on from listing all tracks as being words and music by Genesis to listing those members who contributed to the composition. With ‘Entangled’ Genesis fans got a taste of one of just three songs for which Steve Hackett was credited.
Over the rooftops and houses
Lost as it tries to be seen
Fields of incentive covered with green”
In this piece Steve Hackett wrote the verse and Tony Banks offered the chorus and captivating synthesizer. Tony Banks lists ‘Entangled’ as his favourite track on the album. ‘Entangled’ begins as a little whimsical but by the time it develops and concludes it becomes quite cynical and thought provoking.
For some reason ‘Mad Man Moon’ appears as a sort of orphan track on ‘A Trick of the Tail’. It closes side one which is a good album placement as it always leaves a moment for the listener to ponder. Tony Banks never performed this song live.
Within the valley of shadowless death
They pray for thunderclouds and rain
But to the multitude who stand in the rain
Heaven is where the sun shines”
The lyrical depth is astounding, and listen to his piano work. This is an epic track that demonstrates that in the world of keyboard players few rivalled Tony Banks.
On to side two Genesis led off with ‘Robbery, Assault and Battery’. For this track, Tony Banks continued with his incredible ability to channel what everyone had always thought was the Peter Gabriel vision. His lyrics embody an element of humour and they offer a window to Genesis’s past as a theatrical act. Here, Phil Collins was able to harken back to his past as a stage actor. With ‘Robbery, Assault and Battery’ Phil let everyone know that his new role in the band was permanent and he did it with a flair that was destined to last.
He’s leaving via the roof, the bastard’s got away!
God always fights on the side of the bad man”
Done me wrong. Same old song. We are living this lament to this very day.
The album’s title track offers one more example of Genesis looking to their industry peers for ideas. Musically speaking the song ‘A Trick of the Tail’ was partially inspired by ‘Getting Better’ from The Beatles classic album ‘Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band’. This track has roots that go back to 1972. Tony Banks explains the song’s lyrical influence which were drawn from ‘The Inheritors’ by William Golding.
It’s about a race who were on earth before man and it’s the story of the last survivor of this race. The very last chapter deals with our reaction to him whereas the rest of the story is his reaction to us. It’s about an alien with horns and a tail who appears in a modern city and how people react to him.”
Interestingly, with ‘A Trick of the Tail’ we also get what exists as the first Genesis video. It was produced by Bruce Gowers, who is famous for his work on Queen’s ‘Bohemian Rhapsody’.
Let me take you there
Show you a living story
Let me show you others such as me
Why did I ever leave?”
Watch the video. It’s a cool look back at an iconic band. Enjoy the effect of the four of them dancing on the piano keys.
‘A Trick of the Tail’ concludes with ‘Los Endos’ which is one of just two tracks on the album that credits all four band members. Paired with ‘Dance on a Volcano’, ‘Los Endos’ serves to book end the album. Musically speaking it was a Phil Collins creation inspired by the Santana instrumental ‘Promise of a Fisherman’. Check this out.
As this Genesis instrumental unfolded its opening section was taken from ‘It’s Yourself’ which had gone unreleased until it was added as a B-side to none other than ‘Los Endos’.
I wanted to get all of that energy and melody in there.”
Here is a live version from the 1976 tour to support ‘A Trick of the Tail’.
Logistics for the ‘A Trick of the Tail’ tour required that Genesis find someone to play drums while Phil Collins was handling the vocal responsibilities. It was Bill Bruford, formerly of Yes and King Crimson. Who took on the role. How good does it get?
Here is Bill Bruford commenting on the band he so famously joined for this brief period. This is from an interview with ‘Sounds’.
I’d never seen Genesis or heard their albums before. But I respected Phil and knew he wouldn’t be involved in any rubbish.”
Bruford’s presence actually enhanced Genesis and their street credibility in North America. The North American Tour began in London, Ontario in late March and it ended in July of 1976 in Stafford, England. The live tour served to complete the transformation. Reviews from the tour were almost unanimous. Phil Collins had a natural humorous rapport with the audience. Gone were the theatrics that were Peter Gabriel’s captivating calling card. Collins had a different approach. He came across as likeable, and an everyman which was a persona he developed to mass acclaim over the next couple of decades.
For Genesis, a new era had begun.
Music is magic.
Clearly, ‘A Trick of the Tail’ represents Genesis at their finest. Debate amongst yourselves as to where it stands on the list of their finest releases, but its level of quality at what was a very challenging time speaks volumes. Tony Banks resides as the album’s unsung hero. He received song writing credit on every track. For this contribution he remained somewhat humble.
It was very satisfying for us to show that we could carry on … It was great not to have to involve another person too.”
He was also very realistic about the cloud that was hanging over the band.
But there was a lot of fear about whether we could carry on without him,”
In hindsight they recognized that the creative process was easier with one less person to cast doubt on their ideas. Here is Mike Rutherford from an interview in ‘Prog’ magazine.
I think we knew we’d made a good album. It already felt like a new chapter.”
Tony Banks concluded this combination of thoughts when he told Melody Maker;
We had to prove we could do it without Peter. We think it’s the best album we’ve ever done.”
At the time Tony Banks’s words were supported by the success of ‘A Trick of the Tail’ in the U.K. where the album went to #3, matching the success of ‘Selling England by the Pound’. Globally the album climbed into the top 20 in eight countries.
In the end, one person was not surprised by the continued success of Genesis. Here is Peter Gabriel with a succinct assessment.
I had much more confidence in the band’s ability to transcend my departure than they did.”
Through it all the biggest star that emerged was Phil Collins. Reluctant at first, he adapted to the role of front man in his own way. Within a decade he became one of the biggest and most sought- after names in music history.
Today’s look at ‘A Trick of the Tail’ would not be complete without a track-by-track glimpse at the album through the eyes of a variety of musicians over the past 50 years.
Fittingly we will begin with Steve Hackett in a live setting back in 2013. Here is ‘Dance on a Volcano’.
Next up is a Ted Tocks Covers favourite. Here is Fleesh and their cover of ‘Entangled’ which appeared on their 2020 tribute to Genesis called ‘Here it Comes Again’. Fleesh has been shared on several occasions through the years.
A little over thirty years ago a band called Cairo participated in a phenomenal Genesis tribute album called ‘Supper’s Ready’. The whole album is worth listening to, but here is ‘Cairo’s amazing cover of ‘Squonk’.
Perhaps the most under-appreciated track on ‘A Trick of the Tail’ is ‘Mad Man Moon’ which truly resides as a Tony Banks showcase. Enjoy this instrumental cover by Francesco Gazzara who performs simply under just his last name. He released tribute in 2014 on his album ‘Play Me My Song’.
Next up is a cover that was recorded and released on YouTube just two weeks ago in advance of the 50th anniversary of ‘A Trick of the Tail’. Here is ‘Robbery, Assault and Battery’ by Arianna De Lucrezia and Francesco Vaccarezza. Arianna puts her bass prowess on full display and Francesco lays down the drum part in a way that would make Phil Collins proud. Where it really shines is in the vocal interpretation as the pair interpret this piece like a one act play.
Every cover shared in today’s feature exists in reverence to Genesis but this version by Ray Wilson in 2013 demonstrates the magnitude of what it takes to portray this iconic act in the live setting. After Phil Collins announced his departure in 1996, this talented Scottish musician spent three years touring with Tony Banks and Mike Rutherford as Genesis before the remaining duo decided to shut things down.
They basically phoned me up and said, “Ray, we’re not continuing.” I’ve never really felt that I was out of the band as such; it’s just that the band doesn’t exist anymore (laughs). When I heard that, it was just after the Cut tour, about a year and a half ago. I’ve read some articles saying that I was fired and stuff, but to be fair to them, they didn’t phone me up and say, “Ray, you’re fired. We’re going to carry on and we’re going to get somebody else to sing.” Or, “We’re going to carry on and get Phil back.” There was never any of that. They just said, “We’ve decided not to continue because the market doesn’t want us.” I think they didn’t want to completely close the door to ever doing anything again.”
Here is Wilson ‘Live at Radio Trojka’ in 2013. Enjoy!
Next up is Holly Wilson and her cover of the title track from ‘A Trick of the Tail’ which she released on her album ‘Los Éxitos De Genesis En Bossa Nova’. It is this unique interpretation that drew me to this cover and I was not disappointed.
Time for a big finish and appropriately it includes Phil Collins with The Phil Collins Big Band
in 1996. Enjoy ‘Los Endos’ as conducted by the great Quincy Jones live at Montreux Jazz Festival. The ‘Los Endos Suite’ was the 40th anniversary of this celebrated music showcase.
All these years later, as we listen, we reflect on the magnificence of ‘A Trick of the Tail’ and Genesis on the whole. Some may argue that they drifted over the years into something that became a little too commercial but if you spend time with any album released in the ‘80s and ‘90s their prog rock roots were always evident.
One of many remarkable things about ‘A Trick of the Tail’ is that the maturity of the musicianship and resilience belied their years. Steve Hackett is celebrating his 76th birthday as I write which would have made him 26 at the time of the album’s release. Mike Rutherford was only 25. Tony Banks would turn 26 a month after the album’s unveiling and Phil Collins had just turned 25. The fact that they endured such a significant personnel change as losing Peter Gabriel is one thing to consider. Still, the fact they surged forward in the face of industry pressure and financial constraints borders on unimaginable. Yet the band played on and turned a negative into a rebirth worthy of the band’s moniker. The more I listen, the more I respect the band and every musician connected with this recording through the years. Genesis fans will debate the band’s library of music and their lexicon of great albums forever. Casting this conversation aside Ted Tocks Covers will state that in terms of the human spirit ‘A Trick of the Tail’ exists as the band’s greatest triumph.
Presently, Phil Collins embodies the very same resilience he and his bandmates displayed half a century ago. Due to several health issues that includes five knee surgeries, kidney failure and a debilitating spinal injury, Collins is presently under 24-hour medical care at the age of 75. Despite all of the setbacks, he still has the resolve of a 25 – year-old declaring that he would love to record and tour again.
I can’t dance
I can’t talk
Only thing about me is the way I walk
I can’t dance
I can’t sing
I’m just standing here selling everything”
Do you know what?
He just might do it.
In the meantime, if you are selling Genesis by the pound, ‘A Trick of the Tail’ is worth its weight in gold.
